I wouldn't buy either.
The sender of a parcel by Royal mail is the one who must make the claim if an item gets damaged. The law because the seller has bought the service from Royal Mail. The buyer then buys the shipping and packing service from the seller.
If the item is bought on a buy it now then the seller MUST stick to the distance selling laws whether private or business.
If sold on auction then the distance selling laws Do Not apply.
Therefore the seller is responsible for shipping TO the customer whatever and however he/ she sells.
I it is an auction then it is up to the seller whether to allow returns but MUST allow for returns if bought on a buy it Now.
I state I am responsible for shipping and will refund if item is lost or damaged in shipping and I refund as soon as I have recieved my compensation from Royal mail...( Sometimes before if it's only a small amount)
Funnily enough in 5 years I have only made four refunds for this (Awaiting compensation for a 5th at the mo...but this is first courier claim not RM)
Dunno whether I am just lucky or what!!!
I have had one or two "Try it on" but if it's valuable always send special delivery never Bother with recorded as did you know the recorded stickers easily come off on some of the plastic mailing sack???? and NEVER stick them to parcel tape... they peel off that too!!!
Anyways I hope my sales pages don't look so horribly aggressive as it really does put people off...Reminds me of That teacher everyone has had that stands and gets yer back up before she puts chalk to chalkboard!!!